How water flow components affect sediment dynamics modeling in a Brazilian catchment

Abstract

Water flows that move slowly in the landscape are not simulated by spatially and physical distributed erosion models and can contribute significantly during rainfall events in the streamflow, making model calibration complex. The goals of this study were: (i) to assess the relative contribution of subsurface and surface runoff to the streamflow at the outlet and (ii) to investigate to what extent the presence of runoff, other than Hortonian overland flow, affects erosion model performance. The Arvorezinha catchment (1.23 km2 – Southern Brazil) is characterized by the cultivation of tobacco under minimum cultivation system on shallow soils. From October 2011 until October 2013, we set up a complementary monitoring program of water chemistry and samples were collected during rainfall-runoff events to analyze dissolved silicon (DSi). The observed hydrograph was separated into two components using DSi: i) surface flow and ii) groundwater + soil water flow. The OpenLISEM model was used to assess the impact of different runoff sources and understand the hydrological and erosive process dynamics in the catchment. For this, a manual calibration procedure was used and repeated for two approaches: with and without runoff separation. For the six rainfall events evaluated, 62% of the hydrograph is formed by groundwater + soil water, especially in autumn–winter and for low-medium magnitude events (up to Qpeak = 800 L s−1). The dilution effect was observed during rainfall events, when liquid discharge increases, DSi concentration and suspended sediment concentration decreases. The performance of physics-based models in a catchment with very fragile soils and with frequent changes in land use, is impacted by runoff separation.