How many spirograms for a histamine challenge?

Abstract

Several reports have shown that a prior deep inspiration exerts a blunting effect on pharmacologically induced bronchoconstriction. Inspiration to total lung capacity is a mandatory requirement for valid determination of the FEV1, and thus, the FEV1 may underestimate the magnitude of induced airway obstruction. The present study was designed to assess the effect that the performance and separate analysis of 2 consecutive FEV1 maneuvers (FEV(1)1, FEV(1)2), obtained at different levels of histamine-induced bronchoconstriction, may have on the final interpretation of a histamine challenge. Eight asymptomatic nonsmoking asthmatics (mean age, 24 yr; range, 19 to 27 yr) underwent a total of 16 histamine challenges. Paired FEV1 measurements (FEV(1)1, FEV(1)2) were obtained after inhalation of buffer solution (control) and 3 min after inhalation of aerosolized, serially diluted, histamine diphosphate solutions. A significant airways response (FEV1 decreasing by 20% or more from the control value) was observed in all subjects after inhalation of 5 mg/ml of histamine or less, indicating histamine airway hypersensitivity. At lower doses of histamine the mean values for FEV(1)1 and FEV(1)2 were similar to the control value. At higher histamine doses FEV(1)2 was consistently higher than FEV(1)1 (p = 0.007) and exceeded FEV1 1 by a mean of 9% after inhalation of the provocational histamine concentration; delta FEV1(FEV(1)2-FEV(1)1) was correlated with the log10 of cumulative inhaled histamine dose units (p = 0.040). Assuming that the difference between corresponding FEV1 determinations at a given level of induced bronchoconstriction is a direct consequence of changes in lung mechanics induced by deep inspiration, we are led to conclude that during histamine inhalation challenges, only 1 spirogram should be performed at each level of induced bronchoconstriction.