How Effective are Alternative Ways of Laundry Washing?

Abstract

Abstract Laundry washing consumes resources. It is therefore a clear task for everyone, especially the industry and the consumer, to try to reduce the amount of resources needed as much as possible. Many possibilities and alternatives to the classical cleaning process using a washing machine and a readily formulated detergent are in discussion and are offered to the consumer. Task of this study is to investigate the effectiveness of some of these alternative methods to see whether the task to save resources can be accomplished by them. This is done by carrying out washing performance tests in a common household washing machine using stain monitors and stain strips as indicators for the washing effect in a 30°C and 60°C cotton program and comparing those alternatives (soap nuts, soapwort, two kind of wash-balls) with the use of regular detergent and washing with pure water. As result it is shown, that none of the investigated alternative cleaning methods does deliver any washing effect better than the result achieved with pure water, besides for soapwort that also included other surfactants. Interesting to note that on most stains the use of just 50% of the detergent delivers already a cleaning performance not much lower as 100% of detergent does provide.