Abstract

Preventing infectious disease has often been the primary rationale for public investment in sanitation. However, broader aspects of sanitation such as privacy and safety are important to users across settings, and have been linked to mental wellbeing. The aim of this study is to investigate what people most value about sanitation in low-income areas of Maputo, Mozambique, to inform a definition and conceptual model of sanitation-related quality of life. Our approach to qualitative research was rooted in economics and applied the capability approach, bringing a focus on what people had reason to value. We undertook 19 in-depth interviews and 8 focus group discussions. After eliciting attributes of “a good life” in general, we used them to structure discussion of what was valuable about sanitation. We applied framework analysis to identify core attributes of sanitation-related quality of life, and used pile-sorting and triad exercises to triangulate findings on attributes’ relative importance. The five core attributes identified were health, disgust, shame, safety, and privacy. We present a conceptual model illustrating how sanitation interventions might improve quality of life via changes in these attributes, and how changes are likely to be moderated by conversion factors (e.g. individual and environmental characteristics). The five capability-based attributes are consistent with those identified in studies of sanitation-related insecurity, stress and motives in both rural and urban areas, which is supportive of theoretical generalisability. Since two people might experience the same toilet or level of sanitation service differently, quality of life effects of interventions may be heterogeneous. Future evaluations of sanitation interventions should consider how changes in quality of life might be captured.

Highlights

  • Preventing infectious disease has often been the primary rationale for public investment in sanitation, defined as the separation of human excreta from human contact (WHO, 2018)

  • The aim of this study is to investigate what people most value about sanitation in a low-income urban setting, to inform a definition and conceptual model of sanitation-related quality of life

  • We present findings for each of five capabilities which are core attributes of sanitation-related quality of life (QoL), representing what participants most valued about sanitation in this setting: health, avoiding disgust, avoid­ ing shame, safety, and privacy

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Preventing infectious disease has often been the primary rationale for public investment in sanitation, defined as the separation of human excreta from human contact (WHO, 2018). It is “a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being” (WHO, 1948) Sanitation affects these broader aspects of health. A systematic re­ view of the relationship between sanitation and mental well-being identified privacy and safety as root dimensions, predominantly based on qualitative studies (Sclar et al, 2018). Aspects underlying these di­ mensions were identified as shame, anxiety, fear, assault, dignity and embarrassment. Beyond mental well-being, cleanliness and convenience are commonly reported as important by users (Novotný et al, 2018) We denote these aspects emphasised by users as “quality of life attributes”. They are rarely measured in impact evalua­ tions of sanitation programmes, which predominantly focus on disease (Wolf et al, 2018) and toilet use (Garn et al, 2017)

Objectives
Methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call