How can interventions of building renovation and household energy conversion effectively improve the physical and mental health outcomes? A systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

Household energy efficiency measures can effectively reduce indoor air pollution and positively impact the health of residents, but there is no conclusive evidence on the effectiveness of different energy efficiency measures for various diseases. This study used systematic review and meta-analysis to research the effects of two interventions on residents’ physical and mental health: building renovation (heating, insulation, double-glazed windows and ventilation) and household energy conversion (stove upgrading and clean energy use). A total of 79 papers published between 1977 and 2023 were reviewed in this study, providing comprehensive meta-analytic evidence on the effectiveness of energy efficiency measures. The results show that household energy-saving measures have a minor but significant positive influence on residents’ physical and mental health, with the effect on mental health being larger than the impact on physical health. Stove upgrading is advantageous in respiratory and cardiovascular diseases; insulation can greatly reduce the risk of skin diseases; heating is beneficial in sensory and digestive diseases; and clean energy use can successfully mitigate integrative diseases. Furthermore, a combination of heating and insulation measures has the most favourable influence on mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety and social isolation. The study findings can help residents, policymakers and relevant organizations take appropriate interventions to promote residents’ physical and mental health.