Horizontal tooth displacement and premolar occurrence in elephants and other elephantiform proboscideans

Abstract

Modern elephants lack permanent premolars and their cheek teeth succeed one another by an unusual horizontal tooth displacement mechanism. The fossil record demonstrates that this mechanism characterises elephantimorph proboscideans and first evolved in the late Oligocene. Horizontal tooth displacement provides elephantimorphs with an adaptive advantage over more primitive proboscideans with vertical tooth replacement and concurrent function of all adult teeth. Premolars were lost convergently in diverse elephantimorph taxa with small or no lower tusks and foreshortened symphyses, including independently in crown elephant genera. New evidence reveals the presence of premolars in early species of Loxodonta and loss of premolars in the Loxodonta clade by the mid-Pliocene. Rare occurrences of premolars in mammoths support the hypothesis that these teeth were lost by suppression of genetic and molecular processes responsible for their development. Retention of premolars in Elephas planifrons indicates independent loss of premolars in Elephas and mammoths, and that Elephas had multiple migrations out of Africa, once pre- and once post-loss of premolars in the genus. Unfortunately, the effects of dwarfing are thought to obscure the phylogenetic affinities of fossil elephants from Sulawesi and Java in the genus Stegoloxodon that retain permanent premolars.