History can be more important than 'pollination syndrome' in determining the genetic structure of plant populations: the case of aconitum lycoctonum (Ranunculaceae)

Abstract

The Aconitum lycoctonum complex is a widespread yellow-flowered group of species found in central and southern Europe. Because of extreme morphological variability, the systematics of this group is confusing, and hybridizations among taxa are often hypothesized. To determine whether hybridization, realized mating system within populations or colonization from different Pleistocene refugia might explain some of the morphological variation, the genetic structure of 19 populations from central and southern Europe was studied using starch gel electrophoresis and 10 enzyme loci, of which eight were polymorphic. A pattern typical of an outcrossing species was expected because A. lycoctonum flowers are adapted to pollination by long-tongued bumblebees. However, heterozygosity was very low (between 0.031 and 0.150), which is atypical of either widespread or outcrossing species. The inbreeding coefficient, FIS, also suggested inbreeding in more than half the populations. Analysis of molecular variance showed that 31% of the genetic variation is found among populations, again suggesting inbreeding. A neighbour-joining tree based on Reynolds's genetic distance showed a clear separation between the central/eastern European populations and the samples from the Iberian peninsula and Alpes Maritimes. These data are consistent with the hypothesized refugia and the phylogeographical histories of several European forest trees. The genetic identity of all populations was very high, suggesting that all investigated populations belong to the same species despite high morphological variability. Hybridization was not supported by the data.