Historical Status of Fish Populations in Canadian Rocky Mountain Lakes Inferred from Subfossil Chaoborus (Diptera: Chaoboridae) Mandibles

Abstract

We used subfossil Chaoborus mandibles preserved in sediments of Cabin, Caledonia, and Celestine lakes, Alberta, to determine whether fish were present in the lakes (which now contain rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and lake chub (Couesius plumbeus)) prior to the first fish stockings early this century. We first tested whether Chaoborus were good indicators of the presence of fish in montane lakes in a survey of 43 lakes in jasper and Banff national parks. Chaoborus americanus was the only species inhabiting fishless lakes and was also found in three lakes with low fish density (co-occurring with C. flavicans in two of the three lakes). Other lakes containing fish had either C. flavicans or no Chaoborus species. Subfossils revealed that C. americanus was the predominant species prior to this century in Cabin and Celestine lakes, suggesting that these lakes were originally fishless; C. americanus (and C. trivittatus in Cabin Lake) were eliminated early this century, contemporarily with the first recorded fish stockings. Chaoborus flavicans was the only species recovered from Caledonia Lake, suggesting that the lake had fish prior to this century; while it is not possible to identify the species originally present, historical evidence suggests that rainbow trout is native to Caledonia Lake.