Historical Research on Aerosol Number Concentrations, Classifications of Air Pollution Severity and Particle Retention: Lessons for Present-Day Researchers

Abstract

Research into the adverse health effects of air pollution exposure has repeatedly considered smaller particles, to the point where particle number concentration might be a more relevant metric than mass concentration. Here, we highlight some historical research which developed metrics for air pollution severity based on particle number concentration. Because this work was published in a national journal and prior to the internet and open access, this historical research is not easy to find, and it was more through the history of the aerosol research community in Ireland that this work is now being presented. Multiple online searches for published research papers on “particle number concentrations” and “air pollution severity” were undertaken. Even when specific searches were undertaken using the author names and publication year, these featured papers were not found on any internet search. O’Dea and O’Connor proposed that air pollution severity could be classified based on particle number concentration of condensation nuclei, with ‘little’ air pollution <50 × 103 particles per cm3, ‘mean’ 50–70 × 103 particles per cm3, ‘strong’ 70–100 × 103 particles per cm3, and ‘very strong’ >100 × 103 particles per cm3. Applying their assumptions on density and mean particle size, equated to mass concentrations for a mean of 6 µgm−3, strong at 8.5 µgm−3, and very strong >10 µgm−3. These are consistent with the current WHO guideline values for PM2.5. Additionally, we highlight the 1955 work by Burke and Nolan on the retention of inhaled particles, where ~40% of the inhaled number concentration is retained in the respiratory system. This is also consistent with the more recently published work on particle retention. In summary, the proposed categories of pollution severity, based on number concentrations, could form a basis for the development of future guidelines. This paper highlights that sometimes research has already been published, but it is difficult to find. We challenge researchers to find publications from their own countries which pre-date the WWW to inform current and future research. Additionally, there is scope for a repository for such information on historical publications. We have presented historical research on aerosol number concentrations, classifications of air pollution severity, and particle retention, which present lessons for current researchers.