Historic ocean acidification of Loch Sween revealed by correlative geochemical imaging and high-resolution boron isotope analysis of Boreolithothamniom cf. soriferum

Abstract

Ocean Acidification (OA) arises from the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration following the industrial revolution. The ecological and socio-economic consequences of OA were first identified around 10–15 years ago but remain poorly understood. This is particularly true in coastal regions where local processes can have dramatic consequences on pH trends through time, obscuring and compounding the long-term effects from rising atmospheric CO2. Here we explore the possibility of generating long records of coastal ocean pH using the skeletons of widely distributed coralline algae (CA). The skeletons of these slow growing (<1 mm/year) taxa often contain micron-scale heterogeneities, making sampling for high-resolution climate reconstructions using bulk sampling techniques difficult. Here we use laser ablation coupled to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometers to generate high-resolution 2D images of the element/calcium ratios and boron isotope composition (δ11B) of a sample of Boreolithothamniom cf. soriferum from Loch Sween in Scotland, UK where we have been monitoring temperature since 2004 and pH during 2014. By carefully correlating the geochemical images with a scanning electron microscopy image we can segment them to remove the marginal portions of the skeleton, isolating the central growth axis to generate an age model and growth rate. The δ11B-pH is significantly elevated above the seawater pH in Loch Sween (8.4 to 8.9 vs. 7.9 to 8.1) consistent with other CA that show internal pH elevation. On a seasonal scale, internal pH is negatively correlated with temperature and also exhibits a long-term decline. By removing this temperature effect, internal pH can be correlated to seawater pH during the 2014 monitoring period allowing us to reconstruct a seawater acidification trend from 2004 to 2018 of -0.018 pH units per year, 10x higher than open ocean trends but consistent with contemporaneous monitoring efforts of UK coastal waters. Reconstructed aqueous CO2 suggests that prior to ∼2008 Loch Sween was a sink of CO2 but after this date, particularly during the early summer, it was a substantial CO2 source. Comparison of reconstructed aqueous CO2 with a record of calcification rate of our sample of Boreolithothamniom cf. soriferum suggests this acidification and associated rise in local seawater pCO2 may have freed this sample from carbon limitation leading to a recent increase in calcification.