Hippocampal sparing radiotherapy in adults with primary brain tumours: a comparative planning and dosimetric study using IMPT, IMRT and 3DCRT.

Abstract

Abstract Introduction We assessed the feasibility of hippocampal sparing in adults with primary brain tumours using Intensity Modulated Proton Therapy (IMPT) and compared this with Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) and 3D-Conformal Radiotherapy (3DCRT). Methods and Materials 20 patients were identified, and each patient underwent a radiotherapy planning CT scan and 2 MRI scans. A pre-operative diagnostic MRI scan was fused with the planning CT and used for target delineation and a dedicated 3T MRI scan at the time of planning was fused with the CT for hippocampus delineation. 3 hippocampal sparing plans were generated for each patient with specific prescriptions (54Gy/30 fractions, 60Gy/30 fractions and 59.4Gy/33 fractions) using IMPT, IMRT and 3DCRT. Hippocampal sparing was defined as median dose to contralateral hippocampus ≤25Gy without compromising target coverage and organ at risk dose constraints. Results Hippocampal sparing was achieved in 19 patients (95%) with IMPT, 16 patients (80%) with IMRT and 13 patients (65%) with 3DCRT. The largest median hippocampal dose reduction was seen with IMPT, with a mean median hippocampal dose of 4.8Gy (range: 0.0Gy-24.9Gy), 14.6Gy (range: 1.9Gy-21.7Gy), and 16.2Gy (range: 2.3Gy-25.0Gy) for IMPT, IMRT and 3DCRT respectively. Hippocampal sparing IMPT failed in one case with the largest tumour volume (650cc) where 2/3 of the hippocampus overlapped the target volume. Conclusion IMPT as compared to IMRT and 3DCRT plans showed a trend towards significant and effective hippocampal sparing in adult patients with primary brain tumours. We are currently evaluating this in a larger patient cohort and comparing IMPT with VMAT.