High genetic homogeneity of an intertidal marine invertebrate along 8000 km of the Atlantic coast of the Americas

Abstract

Phallusia nigra is a cosmopolitan solitary ascidian with a distinct niger-blue tunic that is considered to be an easy diagnostic feature, even in the field. The wide geographic distribution of this species may have been a result of the overconfidence of taxonomists and ecologists in the assignment of unknown specimens to this species, based on this simple diagnostic character. Indeed, there seems to be a correlation between cosmopolitanism and the presence of few, but very conspicuous diagnostic characters in benthic invertebrate species. Almost invariably, genetic studies have demonstrated that the cosmopolitanism of those species is artificial and that, rather, they are made up of groups of morphologically very similar, but genetically distinct, species. Thus, we decided to verify the specific status of Western Atlantic populations of P. nigra, from Miami (USA) to São Paulo (southeastern Brazil) by estimating genetic variation and population structure levels along the entire range of this ascidian in the Western Atlantic. The analysis of 10 allozyme systems shows high levels of mean heterozygosity ( H=0.28) so that P. nigra has genetic variation levels more related with other invertebrates than to their, phylogenetically closer, chordate relatives (that show lower levels of heterozygosity). The genetic structure of the population was relatively high ( F ST=0.083) for conspecific populations, but much lower than what would be expected if they belonged to different species. High levels of gene identity also indicate that the Western Atlantic population of P. nigra constitutes a single species. This result suggests an extremely high dispersal capability of the larvae of this ascidian or a relatively recent range expansion of its populations. Since this species is commonly found in harbors, the anthropogenic transport (p.e., in ballast water) may have contributed for the observed genetic homogeneity.