Heterogeneity in the fractionation sensitivities of human tumor cell lines: Studies in a three-dimensional model system

Abstract

Current concepts to optimize the therapeutic gain of radiotherapy by hyperfractionation assume that human tumors are less sensitive to fractionation than late reacting normal tissues. The aim of this study was to investigate the extent of the intercell line heterogeneity of fractionation sensitivity of a wide variety of human tumor cell lines in a three-dimensional model system under fully oxic conditions using schedules with one to eight fractions. Biological characteristics of the tumors that correlate with fractionation sensitivity should be identified. A total of 21 cell lines from human tumors maintained as multicellular spheroids consisting of 1000-1500 cells were given fractionated irradiation within a total treatment time of maximally 50 h. Complete dose-spheroid control curves were determined for each fractionation scheme. The spheroid control data were adequately described by the linear quadratic model assuming Poisson statistics. In addition, the induction of a G2 block by a fractionated test dose of seven 3 Gy fractions given at 6-h intervals was determined in spheroid cells using flow cytometry of propidium bromide stained cell nuclei. The fractionation sensitivities of human tumor cells in multicellular spheroids could be characterized by alpha/beta values, ranging from 2.8-37 Gy in dependence on the cell line. The log normally distributed alpha/beta values were positively correlated with the percentage increase in G2/M phase after the fractionated test dose compared to the controls (r = 0.72, p < 0.01), and were associated with the degree of tumor differentiation (p = 0.01, ANOVA F-test). No significant correlation between the log (alpha/beta) values and the surviving fractions at 2 Gy (SF2) or the total doses with 2 Gy per fraction necessary to control 50% of the spheroids (SCD50) was observed. Despite the intercell line variability of the alpha/beta values, the SCD50 values of the different cell lines, given with one and eight fractions or one fraction and 2 Gy per fraction, were closely associated (Spearman rank correlation coefficients: r = 0.89 or r = 0.90, p < 0.0001). Human tumor cell lines showed a marked heterogeneity in the fractionation sensitivity when irradiated as multicellular spheroids and assayed in situ using the spheroid control end point. Therefore, the therapeutic gain of altered fractionation also depends on those biological characteristics of each individual tumor that affects its fractionation sensitivity. Parameters that correlate with fractionation sensitivity of the tumor lines in the spheroid system were identified as grade of tumor differentiation and percentage increase in G2/M cells at the end of an eight-fraction schedule.