Helicobacter pylori in peptic ulcer: have Koch's postulates been fulfilled?

Abstract

This brief review considers whether or not Koch's postulates have been fulfilled for Helicobacter pylori and peptic ulceration. The histological features of peptic ulcer disease in man are active chronic gastritis with antral predominance, duodenal gastric metaplasia and active duodenitis. Other features are hyperpepsinogenaemia, relative postprandial hypergastrinaemia and basal acid hypersecretion. The macroscopic features are duodenal bulb ulceration or lesser curve and antral gastric ulceration. At present, gastric colonization with H. pylori has been produced in small animal species (rats and mice), but the infection is difficult to establish in immunocompetent animals, and histological gastritis is unconvincing. In larger animals the germ-free pig has been the most reliable model but the gastritis tends to be chronic with little activity. The best examples of acute infection are in three 'self-administration' experiments in humans. In these cases acute gastritis with hypochlorhydria developed which, when it converted to active chronic gastritis, tended to be asymptomatic. Either the circumstances were incompatible with ulceration, or the experiments were not continued for the many years necessary to develop peptic ulceration. It is concluded that only one of the many steps required for the development of peptic ulceration has so far been fulfilled, i.e. the ability of H. pylori to produce histological gastritis in a susceptible host.