Heat transfer analysis of single and double U-tube borehole heat exchanger with two independent circuits

Abstract

Borehole heat exchanger (BHE) is a very suitable and cost-effective technology for heat storage and extraction of heat from the ground. In this paper, comprehensive analysis of major influencing parameters on thermal performance of single U-tube BHE (sBHE) and double U-tube BHE (dBHE) was performed by using validated numerical heat transfer model. Combined effect of increasing borehole size and soil or grout thermal conductivity (for different cases of shank spacing) on performance of sBHE and dBHE was studied. Detailed comparative analysis of thermal performance was made among sBHE and dBHE with small and large borehole sizes. The impact of borehole depth and diameter, fluid inlet temperature, mass flow rate, U-tube pipe material type and diameter on total heat transfer per unit borehole depth, borehole thermal resistance and thermal effectiveness was also investigated. The simulation result revealed that when the shank spacing is kept at high or low value in sBHE and dBHE (both with small and large borehole size), dBHE with larger borehole size has the highest thermal performance while sBHE with smaller borehole size has the lowest performance; and the highest and the lowest thermal resistance is obtained for sBHE with smaller borehole size and dBHE with larger borehole size, respectively. Grout with high thermal conductivity is preferred in terms of improving thermal effectiveness and reducing thermal resistance of the BHE when the soil thermal conductivity is sufficiently high; while low grout thermal conductivity is preferred with large borehole size and high shank spacing. For high soil thermal conductivity (4W/m.K), the heat transfer rate per unit borehole depth increases with grout thermal conductivity to a maximum value; and then further increasing of the grout conductivity results in smooth declining of the heat transfer in the BHE. Thus, ground and grout thermal conductivity have an optimal range to achieve a lower value of the BHE thermal resistance, and consequently for better BHE sizing. With increasing fluid inlet temperature (15oC to 42oC), the total heat transfer is improved by 51.5 W/m and 36.2 W/m for dBHE and sBHE respectively; and more heat is injected into the borehole when dBHE is used than sBHE, particularly at higher inlet temperature showing that dBHE is preferable than sBHE for system that works with higher fluid inlet temperature. The result obtained can be used as a quick reference for the design, operation optimization and performance study of ground coupled heat pump system where BHE is used as aborehole thermal energy storage.