Heat current in the magnetic field: Nernst-Ettingshausen effect above the superconducting transition

Abstract

A problem of the definition of the heat transported in thermomagnetic phenomena has been realized well in the late 1960s, but not solved up to date. By ignoring this problem, numerous recent theories grossly overestimate the thermomagnetic coefficients in strongly interacting systems. Here, we develop a gauge-invariant microscopic approach, which shows that the heat transfer should include the energy of the interaction between electrons and a magnetic field. We also demonstrate that the surface currents induced by the magnetic field transfer the charge in the Nernst effect but do not transfer the heat in the Ettingshausen effect. Only with these two modifications of the theory does the physically measurable thermomagnetic coefficients satisfy the Onsager relation. We critically revised the Gaussian-fluctuation theory above the superconducting transition and show that the gauge invariance uniquely relates thermomagnetic phenomena in the Fermi liquid with the particle-hole asymmetry.