Health-Related Quality of Life after Combined External Beam and Either High Dose Rate (HDR) or Low Dose Rate (LDR) Brachytherapy: Does the Rectal Dose from the LDR Brachytherapy Make a Difference?

Abstract

The recently reported randomized Phase III trial comparing health related quality of life (HRQOL) after combined external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) and either HDR or LDR brachytherapy (BT) found a significant decline in the EPIC Bowel domain HRQOL score at 24- 48 months after treatment in the LDR arm of the trial. As all patients in the trial received the same EBRT dose, and HDR rectal dose was strictly controlled to be <9.5 Gy to 1cc of rectal wall (RD1cc), we investigated whether the variable rectal dose from the LDR component of treatment was related to the decline in Bowel HRQOL for these patients. A total of 195 men with upper tier intermediate or high-risk prostate cancer were assigned by a random number generator to receive either an HDR (15 Gy, n = 108) or LDR (110Gy, n = 87) brachytherapy boost combined with 46Gy/23 fractions EBRT. All LDR patients had 1 month post implant quality assurance using CT-MRI fusion. The Expanded Prostate Cancer Composite (EPIC) questionnaire was used to evaluate HRQOL at baseline, q3 mo for 1 year, q6mo for 3 yr and then annually. A multivariate linear regression model was used to investigate the dose-response relationship between EPIC bowel domain score at 24- 48 months and RD1cc. With a median follow up of 48 months, the previous analysis confirmed the expected time course of acute bowel/urinary symptoms, with LDR showing more prolonged decline in HRQOL bowel domain at 3 and 6 months, but equivalence to HDR by 12 months. HRQOL urinary domain remained equivalent from 12-60 mo. The decline in the HRQOL bowel domain observed for LDR patients from 24-48 mo was analyzed for the 79 patients with sufficient data. The mean baseline HRQOL bowel domain score was 92 and fell on average to 85 at 24-48 mo. Mean RD1cc for the LDR patients was 82Gy (SD 22 Gy), with a maximum value of 129 Gy. In this range of rectal doses, a 20Gy increase in RD1cc, was associated on average with a 1.5-point decrease in EPIC HRQOL bowel domain score (p = 0.21). The rectal dose received by the LDR patients showed a non-significant dose-response with the EPIC Bowel domain HRQOL score. This confirms the accepted rectal dose constraints for LDR brachytherapy but does not explain the observed decline in bowel scores from 24-48 months.