Health Impact of Street Sweeps from the Perspective of Healthcare Providers

Abstract

BackgroundHomeless street sweeps are frequent operations in many cities in the USA in which government agencies move unhoused people living in public outdoor areas. Little research exists on the health impact of street sweeps operations.ObjectiveThis study was created at the request of community advocacy groups to investigate and document the health impacts of street sweeps from the perspective of healthcare providers.DesignThis is a qualitative study using data gathered from open-ended questions.ParticipantsWe recruited 39 healthcare providers who provided health and wellness services in San Francisco for people experiencing homelessness (PEH) between January 2018 and January 2020.InterventionsWe administered a qualitative, open-ended questionnaire to healthcare providers using Qualtrics surveying their perspectives on the health impact of street sweeps.ApproachWe conducted qualitative thematic analysis on questionnaire results.Key ResultsStreet sweeps may negatively impact health through two outcomes. The first outcome is material loss, including belongings and medical items. The second outcome is instability, including geographic displacement, community fragmentation, and loss to follow-up. These outcomes may contribute to less effective management of chronic health conditions, infectious diseases, and substance use disorders, and may increase physical injuries and worsen mental health. Providers also reported that sweeps may negatively impact the healthcare system by promoting increased usage of emergency departments and inpatient hospital care.ConclusionsSweeps may have several negative consequences for the physical and mental health of the PEH community and for the healthcare system.