Head‐to‐head comparisons of cognitive screening tests administered in primary care centers

Abstract

AbstractBackgroundCognitive screening tests are often used in primary care to aid in the decision whether further investigation is needed. The most widely used tests, MMSE and the Clock Drawing Test (CDT), were developed more than 40 years ago and there is a need to update the primary care neuropsychological toolbox. The objective for this pilot study was to examine the diagnostic accuracy of AD for different cognitive tests administered at primary care centers.MethodThe BioFINDER Primary Care Study consecutively recruits patients with cognitive complaints (SCD, MCI, or mild dementia) at different primary care centers in Sweden. Cognitive tests are examined as well as plasma AD‐biomarkers. A test battery including MMSE, MoCA, CDT, Verbal fluency tests, TMT A and B, Symbol Digit Test, ADAS 10‐wordlist and Recall of Picture Test (RPT) are administered to all patients at their respective primary care center. Patients are then referred to a memory clinic where they undergo a full clinical work‐up (including neuropsychological assessment, lumbar puncture or Aβ‐PET, MRI and an examination by a physician specialized in dementia diseases) after which a diagnosis is made (blinded to the tests done in primary care). A clinical diagnosis of AD is supported by CSF or PET findings. The diagnosis of AD, either at the MCI or mild dementia stage, was here used as the dependent variable in logistic regression models with the different cognitive tests as predictors (adjusted for age, sex, education). Comparisons of AUC were performed using DeLong statistics.ResultIn this pilot study the first 276 recruited patients were analyzed (Table 1). Four tests, MMSE (AUC = 0.73, P <0.01), MoCA (AUC = 0.71, P <0.05), ADAS 10‐wordlist (AUC = 0.80, P <0.001) and RPT (AUC = 0.79, P <0.001), performed significantly better than the basic model (age, sex, education) in predicting a diagnosis of AD. Both the ADAS 10‐wordlist and RPT performed significantly better than MMSE (P <0.05). Adding the CDT to MMSE did not improve the AUC (0.73).ConclusionIn a diverse population, as seen at primary care centers, brief tests of memory may provide better accuracy in detecting AD than standard of care tests as MMSE and MoCA.