Harsh environmental regimes increase the functional significance of intraspecific variation in plant communities

Abstract

Abstract The relative importance of intraspecific trait variation (rITV) for functional diversity (FD) in plant communities is increasingly apparent, but the influence of abiotic factors on the balance between intraspecific and interspecific effects in contrasting environments is uncertain. Drawing on a novel conceptual and analytic framework, we quantified rITV as the ratio of FD associated with between‐population ITV (Intra_FD) and the interspecific variation (Inter_FD) due to species turnover across sites. We predicted that rITV would increase with environmental harshness as a result of decreasing interspecific variation and concomitant increases in between‐population ITV. We empirically tested this prediction in a comparison of rITV for five traits (mature plant height, SLA, leaf dry matter content and the foliar concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorus (P)) characterizing species in Tibetan alpine meadow communities from contrasting environmental regimes. We found that across sites: (a) rITV for all five traits increased with environmental harshness not only through decreasing Inter_FD but also through increasing Intra_FD; (b) increases in rITV were mostly attributable to declines in soil resources, especially soil P, with lower soil P significantly associated with lower Inter_FD but higher Intra_FD for most traits; and (c) although neither Intra_FD nor Inter_FD was significantly impacted by species richness for any traits, a higher rITV for SLA was significantly associated with low species richness. Taken together, these results support our hypothesis that the functional significance of ITV in plant communities increases with environmental harshness. Moreover, in the Tibetan alpine meadows we studied, the opposing intraspecific and interspecific responses along a gradient of P availability appear to act as a buffering mechanism stabilizing the functional structure of communities on P deficient soils. Our novel conceptual and analytical framework provides a template for evaluating the generality of this favourable mismatch between intraspecific and interspecific responses in FD along environmental gradients. A free Plain Language Summary can be found within the Supporting Information of this article.