GSEA-SDBE: A gene selection method for breast cancer classification based on GSEA and analyzing differences in performance metrics.

Abstract

Selecting the most relevant genes for sample classification is a common process in gene expression studies. Moreover, determining the smallest set of relevant genes that can achieve the required classification performance is particularly important in diagnosing cancer and improving treatment. In this study, I propose a novel method to eliminate irrelevant and redundant genes, and thus determine the smallest set of relevant genes for breast cancer diagnosis. The method is based on random forest models, gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA), and my developed Sort Difference Backward Elimination (SDBE) algorithm; hence, the method is named GSEA-SDBE. Using this method, genes are filtered according to their importance following random forest training and GSEA is used to select genes by core enrichment of Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes pathways that are strongly related to breast cancer. Subsequently, the SDBE algorithm is applied to eliminate redundant genes and identify the most relevant genes for breast cancer diagnosis. In the SDBE algorithm, the differences in the Matthews correlation coefficients (MCCs) of performing random forest models are computed before and after the deletion of each gene to indicate the degree of redundancy of the corresponding deleted gene on the remaining genes during backward elimination. Next, the obtained MCC difference list is divided into two parts from a set position and each part is respectively sorted. By continuously iterating and changing the set position, the most relevant genes are stably assembled on the left side of the gene list, facilitating their identification, and the redundant genes are gathered on the right side of the gene list for easy elimination. A cross-comparison of the SDBE algorithm was performed by respectively computing differences between MCCs and ROC_AUC_score and then respectively using 10-fold classification models, e.g., random forest (RF), support vector machine (SVM), k-nearest neighbor (KNN), extreme gradient boosting (XGBoost), and extremely randomized trees (ExtraTrees). Finally, the classification performance of the proposed method was compared with that of three advanced algorithms for five cancer datasets. Results showed that analyzing MCC differences and using random forest models was the optimal solution for the SDBE algorithm. Accordingly, three consistently relevant genes (i.e., VEGFD, TSLP, and PKMYT1) were selected for the diagnosis of breast cancer. The performance metrics (MCC and ROC_AUC_score, respectively) of the random forest models based on 10-fold verification reached 95.28% and 98.75%. In addition, survival analysis showed that VEGFD and TSLP could be used to predict the prognosis of patients with breast cancer. Moreover, the proposed method significantly outperformed the other methods tested as it allowed selecting a smaller number of genes while maintaining the required classification accuracy.