Growth, survival and fluctuating asymmetry of Iceland scallops in a test of density-dependent growth in a natural bed

Abstract

We report an experiment designed to test for overpopulation in an Iceland scallop, Chlamys islandica (O.F. Müller), slow-growing bed. Scallops were installed in pearl nets at the site of the scallop bed and in a nearby unpopulated site, near the bottom and far from the bottom. With this set-up, all groups, except that one near the bottom inside the bed, were free from potential overpopulation effects. In addition, there were two stocking densities to test for containment effects. Shell growth was higher at 2.0 m above the bottom, outside the scallop bed, than at the three other site and height combinations, which were not significantly different from each other. There was a borderline effect of site on soft tissue growth, which was probably slower at the donor site. We conclude that there was no evidence of overpopulation in the scallop bed. On both sites, soft tissue growth was slowest near the bottom, irrespective of group size, intermediate at 2.0 m height, high population density, and fastest at 2.0 m height, low population density. Survivorship was lower near the bottom, but was independent of site and of group size. Available data showed no sustained vertical patterns in phytoplankton concentration in the water column. These results suggest that food depletion occurred in the pearl nets, but that density-independent factors dominated density-dependent factors in the pearl nets near the bottom. Likely explanations involve the interaction between containment effects and current speed variations in the benthic boundary layer. Survivorship decreased with fluctuating asymmetry of the ears of the shells. Fluctuating asymmetry, therefore, may provide a means of including individual effects in growth experiments and forecasting the ability of spat to resist density-independent mortality agents.