Growth of riparian cottonwoods: a developmental pattern and the influence of geomorphic context

Abstract

Cottonwoods are poplars (Populus sp.) adapted to riparian (streamside) zones and an understanding of their growth within these zones will assist with river management for cottonwood conservation and in the recognition of superior parental genotypes for hybrid poplar breeding programs. In this study we analyzed cottonwood growth in native riparian zones and compared growth along three study reaches of the Oldman River in Alberta, Canada that differed in geomorphic context, particularly the extent that the river channel was constrained by steep banks and bedrock. We used dendrochronology to analyze trunk growth patterns, and measured annual radial increments (RI) and basal area increments (BAI) of 278 narrowleaf cottonwoods (P. angustifolia), black cottonwoods (P. trichocarpa), their intrasectional hybrids, and natural intersectional hybrids with prairie cottonwoods (P. deltoides). The trees displayed common growth patterns with four phases: (I) a 3–7-year establishment phase with RI of about 1–2 mm/year, (II) a growth acceleration phase of about 15 years with RI increasing to the (III) RI growth peak of about 3 mm/year, and then (IV) the mature growth phase with relatively constant BAI and progressively declining RI. This general pattern was consistent across study reaches but the durations and growth rates of the phases differed along with forest stand structure. Along the unconstrained alluvial reach with a broad floodplain and dynamic channel, extensive and dense forest groves occurred. This increased tree competition, as evidenced by reduced RI and BAI in the mature phase. In contrast, along a constrained reach trees were restricted to sparse, narrow bands and their increased growth rates in the mature phase probably reflected reduced competition. Cottonwoods along the intermediate reach demonstrated an intermediate combination of forest and growth characteristics. Genotypic effects were slight although P. angustifolia had reduced RI during the establishment phase. These results demonstrate that within native riparian zones cottonwoods display an inherent growth pattern that reflects the trees' life history, and that growth rates and transitions are influenced by the geomorphic context that influences forest structure.