Growth and Tissue Elemental Composition Response of Butterhead Lettuce (Lactuca sativa, cv. Flandria) to Hydroponic and Aquaponic Conditions

Tyler Anderson,Michael Timmons,David De Villiers

doi:10.3390/horticulturae3030043

Abstract

The primary objective of this research was to compare lettuce performance under conventional hydroponics at pH 5.8 (referred to as H5), hydroponics at pH 7.0 (referred to as H7), and recirculated aquaponic water at pH 7.0 (referred to as A7). Aquaponic nutrients were supplied by continuously recirculating water between a fish rearing system (recirculating aquaculture system or RAS) and the lettuce growing system (with the sole addition being chelated iron). This paper builds upon our previous research where we found that H7 produced 26% less shoot fresh weight (FW) growth than H5 and an 18% reduction in dry weight (DW). In this research, we also evaluated the inorganic hydroponics nutrient solution at pH 7.0 (H7) to provide continuity between experiments and to isolate the pH effect. The A7 plant biomass responses were not different from H5 in all biomass response categories. H7 was different from H5 in shoot FW, DW, and DW/FW, as well as root FW and DW. H7 was different from the A7 in shoot FW, DW/FW, and root DW. There were no tissue elemental differences between H5 and H7 except Cu. The Ca and Na contents differed between H5 and A7, while the microelements Mn, Mo, and Zn differed. Generally, the elemental tissue differences between treatments were proportional to the differences for the same elements in the nutrient solutions. Aquaponic systems are often viewed to be more complicated and more risky because two complex systems are being joined (hydroponics plus RAS). However, the aquaponics system proved to be surprisingly simple to manage in daily operations. Our data suggested that the aquaponics system (A7), which was operated at a higher pH 7.0, was able to offset any negative biomass and elemental effects that occurred in the inorganic hydroponic pH 7.0 treatment (H7) from its increased pH and less optimized nutrient solution elemental concentrations.

Highlights

Hydroponics is the soil-less culture of plants in nutrient solution that contains ions of all of the necessary elements for good plant growth
The treatments investigated included a conventional hydroponics nutrient solution with pH controlled at pH 5.8, the conventional hydroponics nutrient solution maintained at an elevated pH 7.0, and a continuously recirculating aquaponics system maintained at pH 7.0
This experiment demonstrated that aquaponics high quality in both and precipitation was unique to the hydroponic pH can

Summary

Introduction

Hydroponics is the soil-less culture of plants in nutrient solution that contains ions of all of the necessary elements for good plant growth. Resh [1] provides a review of the major hydroponic production systems, e.g., nutrient film technique (NFT), deep water culture (DWC) or raft [2], and soil-less media beds. Hydroponics is an increasingly important field due to its increased nutrient, water, and space use efficiencies [3]. Another form of sustainable food production is from recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS) that produce aquatic and/or marine organisms. RAS is an intensive form of fish or other aquatic organism production ( referred to as fish for brevity) using supplemental aeration and biological filtration to maintain the necessary water quality conditions [4].

Objectives

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion