Growth, abnormalities, and mortality of tadpoles of American toad exposed to combinations of malathion and nitrate

Abstract

American toad tadpoles (Bufo americanus) were exposed to malathion and nitrate in a fully factorial experiment that crossed four concentrations of malathion ranging between 0 and 1,000 µg malathion/L, and five concentrations of nitrate ranging from 0 to 16 mg NO(3) -N/L to identify single and interactive effects. In this 21-d experiment, we recorded tadpole length, mass, survivorship, and frequencies of diamond-shaped and stiff-tail abnormalities. Malathion increased frequency of diamond-shaped and stiff-tail abnormalities, and negatively affected survivorship, but did not affect tadpole size. Nitrate did not affect survivorship but did have sublethal effects, including effects on tadpole length and the frequency of both abnormalities. The interaction of malathion and nitrate has no effect on survivorship or tadpole size but did affect the frequency of abnormalities, with nitrate reducing malathion's effect. Results of the present study suggest that at the environmentally realistic concentrations used in our experiment, malathion has both lethal and sublethal effects, but nitrate had only sublethal effects on American toad tadpoles. The combination of malathion and nitrate had limited effects at the tested concentrations under laboratory conditions. However, the effect of the combined treatments on the frequency of tadpole developmental abnormalities suggests that such interactions may play a role under field conditions, in which pesticide and nitrate fertilizers are typically applied simultaneously.