Group members’ questions shape participation in health counselling and health education

Abstract

ObjectiveThis study examines how group members’ questions shape member participation in health counselling and health education groups. MethodsThe study applies conversation analytic principles as a method. The data consist of video-recorded health education lessons in secondary school and health counselling sessions for adults with a high risk of Type 2 diabetes. ResultsGroup members’ questions accomplish a temporary change in participatory roles. They are used to 1) request counselling, 2) do counselling or 3) challenge previous talk. They are usually treated as relevant and legitimate actions by the participants, but are occasionally interpreted as transitions outside the current action or topic. ConclusionGroup members’ questions result in a shift from leader-driven to member-driven discussion. Thus they constitute a pivot point for detecting changes in participation in group interventions. Practice implicationsObserving the occurrence of group members’ questions helps group leaders to adjust their own actions accordingly and thus facilitate or guide group participation. Comparison of the type and frequency of members’ questions is a way to detect different trajectories for delivering group interventions and can thus be used to develop methods for process evaluation of interventions.