Abstract

I argue for a distinction between two types of positive polarity items (PPIs) which has not been recognized so far. While for some PPIs, anti-licensing is a strictly local phenomenon, for other PPIs anti-licensing should be stated as a global condition. I aim to contribute to a principled explanation for the distribution of a significant subset of global PPIs, by relating it to specific semantic properties of the relevant items. More specifically, I argue that PPIs such as soit ... soit ..., quelques and almost trigger obligatory exhaustivity effects and scalar inferences, and that independently motivated constraints regarding the generation of such inferences can account for their distribution. The paper also briefly addresses the case of other global PPIs, e.g., at least, for which a similar account is not straightforwardly available. http://dx.doi.org/10.3765/sp.7.11 BibTeX info

Highlights

  • Szabolcsi 2002 — and in French), for other positive polarity items (PPIs) anti-licensing should be stated as a global condition

  • I have argued that positive polarity items should be distinguished according to whether their anti-licensing conditions apply locally or globally

  • For a number of global PPIs, the relevant anti-licensing condition can be reduced to an independently motivated hypothesis — namely, that they have to occur in the scope of an exhaustivity operator or in positions where they can trigger strengthened presuppositions

Read more

Summary

Introduction

It argues for a distinction between two types of positive polarity items (PPIs) which has not been recognized so far. The proposal will be extended to English almost and French quelques Items such as at least cannot be treated in the same way. These notations have a relative character, i.e., they are used to report contrasts

Core properties of PPIs
Types of PPIs
Operator anti-licensing and environment anti-licensing
Restrictors and negated factive verbs
Other complex disjunctions
Accounting for the distribution of complex disjunctions
Complex disjunctions and exclusivity inferences
Constraint regulating the distribution of exh
Remaining issues: when exhaustification is vacuous yet licensed
Restrictors and factive intervention
Restrictors and scalar implicated presuppositions
Factive intervention
Another global PPI: almost
Almost and negative implicata
Almost and obligatory exhaustification
Predicting the distribution of almost
Other global PPIs
At least
Approximately
Conclusion
Predictions to be tested
Procedure and material
Data treatment
Results
Detailed description of the survey
B Data on the distribution of almost
Material
Findings
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call