Glenohumeral Superior Translation and Subacromial Contract Pressure Are Both Improved With Superior Capsular Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Biomechanical Investigations

Abstract

PurposeTo review cadaveric studies evaluating the biomechanical outcomes of superior capsular reconstruction (SCR) with different graft types for the treatment of irreparable rotator cuff (RTC) tears. MethodsPubMed, Cochrane, and Embase were queried in January 2022 to conduct this meta-analysis using the following key words: “superior capsule reconstruction,” “superior capsular reconstruction,” and “biomechanics.” Articles were included if they reported glenohumeral superior translation or subacromial contact pressure following SCR in cadaveric RTC tears. The review adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses criteria. Number of shoulders, graft types, and biomechanical outcomes were recorded and analyzed with forest plots. ResultsTwelve studies (95 shoulders) were included in the statistical analysis. There was a significant reduction in glenohumeral superior translation following SCR compared with RTC tear across 10 studies (79 shoulders) with standardized mean difference (SMD) –2.48 mm; confidence interval (CI) –3.28 mm, –1.69 mm. The SMD between fascia lata graft and RTC tear was –3.84 mm (CI –4.82 mm, –2.86 mm) and between dermal allograft and RTC tear was –2.05 mm (CI –3.10 mm, –1.00 mm). There was a significant reduction in subacromial contact pressure following SCR compared with RTC tear across 5 studies (55 shoulders) with SMD –3.49 MPa (CI –4.54 MPa, –2.44 MPa). The SMD between fascia lata graft and RTC tear was –3.21 MPa (CI –5.08 MPa, –1.34 MPa) and between dermal allograft and RTC tear was –3.89 MPa (CI –5.91 MPa, –1.87 MPa). ConclusionsIndependent of graft type, biomechanical studies suggest that SCR improves glenohumeral superior translation and subacromial contact pressure in comparison with RTC tear at time zero. There was no definitive evidence identified in this study to suggest a biomechanically superior SCR graft option. Clinical RelevanceInvestigating the biomechanical outcomes of several graft types for superior capsular reconstruction will help surgeons better understand the efficacies of different graft types for use in superior capsule reconstruction surgery.