Giant sequoia regeneration in group selection openings in the southern Sierra Nevada

Abstract

Fire has been linked to the regeneration of giant sequoia ( Sequoiadendron giganteum) [Lindley] Buchholz but no studies have directly investigated the effects of opening size and fuel treatment on giant sequoia establishment. Giant sequoia seedling density was analyzed in 36 group selection openings harvested in 1993 at Mountain Home Demonstration State Forest, CA. The experiment consisted of four replicates of a randomized 3 × 3 factorial design which investigated the effects of opening size and fuel treatment on giant sequoia regeneration. Small, medium, and large circular openings had average diameters of 15, 30, and 61 m, respectively. A total of 12 large, 12 medium, and 12 small openings were created. Three fuel treatments were randomly applied to the openings: tractor pile and burn, broadcast burn, and lop and scatter. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) detected no significant differences between treatments and seedling density ( p < 0.05). All the treatments had low giant sequoia seedling density regardless of opening size or fuel treatment. Regeneration was completely absent in all openings with the lop and scatter fuel treatment while small openings had low giant sequoia regeneration density regardless of fuel treatment. Giant sequoia seedling density was low because of below average annual and summer precipitation following the creation of the openings and of low seed dispersal. The group selection silvicultural system attempts to simulate the structural complexity of the prehistoric, patchy, high intensity fire regime that once existed in the mixed-conifer forests of the southern Sierra Nevada but important ecosystem processes such as increased seed dispersal following patchy, high intensity fire and large scale nutrient cycling are not duplicated.