Giant cerebral cavernous malformations: redefinition based on surgical outcomes and systematic review of the literature.

Abstract

Giant cerebral cavernous malformations (GCCMs) are rare vascular malformations. Unlike for tumors and aneurysms, there is no clear definition of a "giant" cavernous malformation (CM). As a result of variable definitions, working descriptions and outcome data of patients with GCCM are unclear. A new definition of GCCM related to surgical outcomes is needed. An institutional database was searched for all patients who underwent resection of CMs > 1 cm in diameter. Patient information, surgical technique, and clinical and radiographic outcomes were assessed. A systematic review was performed to augment an earlier published review. In the authors' institutional cohort of 183 patients with a large CM, 179 with preoperative and postoperative modified Rankin Scale (mRS) scores were analyzed. A maximum CM diameter of ≥ 3 cm was associated with greater risk of severe postoperative decline (≥ 2-point increase in mRS score). After adjustment for age and deep versus superficial location, size ≥ 3 cm was strongly predictive of severe postoperative decline (OR 4.5, 95% CI 1.2-16.9). A model with CM size and deep versus superficial location was developed to predict severe postoperative decline (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.79). Thirteen more patients with GCCMs have been reported in the literature since the most recent systematic review, including some patients who were treated earlier and not discussed in the previous review. The authors propose that cerebral CMs with a diameter ≥ 3 cm be defined as GCCMs on the basis of the inflection point for functional and neurological outcomes. This definition is in line with the definitions for other giant lesions. It is less exclusive than earlier definitions but captures the rarity of these lesions (approximately 1% incidence) and variation in outcomes. GCCMs remain operable with potentially favorable outcomes. The term "giant" is not meant to deter or contraindicate surgery.