Genomic and common garden data reveal significant genetic differentiation in the endangered San Fernando Valley spineflower Chorizanthe parryi var. fernandina

Abstract

San Fernando Valley spineflower (Chorizanthe parryi var. fernandina [S. Watson] Jeps.) (Polygonaceae) is an herbaceous annual plant, endemic to California, and until rediscovered in 1999 had been thought to be extinct for almost seven decades. Historically documented at 10 locations, it currently persists at 2, separated by approximately 27 km. State listed as endangered, a description of its genetic diversity and structure is of conservation interest. After determining a lack of variation in ploidy, we examined genetic variation from samples within both populations: a common garden study for potentially adaptive genetic variation in selected growth and phenological traits and analysis of single nucleotide polymorphisms identified through restriction-site associated DNA sequencing. Both measures indicated that this highly restricted taxon nevertheless harbors substantial levels of genetic diversity and has significant between- and within-population genetic structure. Combining approaches from population genomics and common garden studies provided more insight into the patterns and basis of genetic diversity than is typical for studies of non-model species. Although local adaptation was not specifically studied (i.e., via reciprocal transplant studies), the differences determined from these two independent lines of evidence indicate that mixing gene pools between populations is not recommended at this time. Further, with significant differences revealed among subpopulations, we caution against mixing genotypes across subpopulations for the most part, and without much more evidence that this would not pose a risk of outbreeding depression. The importance of supporting pollinator health and diversity is highlighted. With genetic diversity—particularly with an annual species—being dynamic, fluctuating with the usual processes and with contributions from the soil seedbank, we recommend periodic resampling to monitor genetic diversity and structure. Climate change is anticipated to contribute to this variability.