Genetic evidence for cryptic speciation in the marine bryozoan Alcyonidium gelatinosum

Abstract

The common subtidal marine bryozoan Alcyonidium gelatinosum (L.) is one of the most confusing species of a taxonomically very difficult genus. It shows massive variation for almost all morphological characters. A number of sympatric colonies collected off the coast of Lundy (Bristol Channel) could be clearly divided on morphological grounds into two quite distinct types. Using starch gel electrophoresis the products of a range of genetic enzyme loci were compared between the two morphotypes and also between these and other Bristol Channel populations of A. gelatinosum. Minimal differences were observed between one Lundy morphotype and the other allopatric populations, which it was consequently concluded were conspecific. The second morphotype showed considerable genetic differentiation [genetic identity (Nei, 1972) =0.417] from the other Lundy population, with no common alleles at some loci. The probability of obtaining the observed results by chance in a single population is significantly low (P<10−14). It is therefore concluded that the two morphotypes of A. gelatinosum from Lundy are not conspecific.