Genetic characterization of Salix alba L. and Salix fragilis L. by means of different PCR-derived marker systems

Abstract

Salix alba L. and Salix fragilis L. are two closely related willow species whose phenotypic features, showing a large and continuous variation, have a low diagnostic value for identifying pure species and interspecific hybrids. In this paper, the effectiveness of different multilocus PCR-based molecular markers, such as I-SSRs, RAPDs and AFLPs in detecting genetic polymorphisms able to discriminate the two willow species was evaluated by analysing a set of 12 reference samples. Three genetic similarity indexes, Dice, Jaccard and Simple Matching coefficient, were used for all possible pairwise comparisons of individuals, revealing the same trend of variation within and between species when different marker systems were used. Cluster analysis, based on Dice genetic similarity coefficient, clustered the individuals of S. alba and S. fragilis into two distinct subgroups, indicating that the gene pools are well differentiated. Moreover, a number of private alleles for each marker system allowed the discrimination of the two species because always present only in one of the two. The utility of different marker systems in discriminating willow species was evaluated by the Polymorphism Information Content (PIC) and the Marker Index (MI) parameters. The variation of Dice's indexes obtained from a different number of experiments in relation to the marker systems is discussed.