Genesis of the Hujiazhuang apatite-rich carbonatite complex in North China and its implication for the REE fertility of the carbonatite system

Abstract

Apatite is a common REE-compatible mineral in carbonatites, so its formation can affect the REE ore-forming potential of carbonatite systems. In nature, there are numerous apatite-rich carbonatite complexes, but the petrogenesis of these complexes has long been debated. To resolve this controversy, this study conducts elemental and isotopic analyses on the Mesozoic (∼120 Ma) Hujiazhuang carbonatite complex in North China. The Hujiazhuang complex contains magnetite-calcite-apatite carbonatites and calcite carbonatites. Calcite grains from these two rock phases exhibit identical initial 87Sr/86Sr ratios (0.71027–0.71038), indicating a common parental magma derived from a metasomatized lithosphere mantle. Then, from magnetite-calcite-apatite carbonatites to calcite carbonatites, the Mg, Fe, and Mn contents of calcite continuously increase while the Sr and REE contents decrease, consistent with elemental variations of calcite during fractional crystallization of carbonatitic magma. Therefore, these two lithologies are proposed to be formed through fractional crystallization of a common magma. Notably, the Hujiazhuang carbonatite complex was derived from a metasomatized lithosphere mantle and experienced intensive fractionation, which potentially facilitate the formation of REE deposits. However, this complex cannot meet REE's economic standard. The early-stage magnetite-calcite-apatite carbonatites have high REE contents (3,675–11,075 ppm), and a positive correlation can be observed between REE and P contents in this lithology. It indicates that early, extensive crystallization of apatite led to REE dispersion, largely hindering REE enrichment in later stages. In general, this study provides important insights into the genesis of the apatite-rich carbonatite complex and advances our understanding of the REE dispersion or enrichment behaviors in carbonatite system.