General Principles and Limitations for Detection of RNA Modifications by Sequencing.

Abstract

ConspectusAmong the many analytical methods applied to RNA modifications, a particularly pronounced surge has occurred in the past decade in the field of modification mapping. The occurrence of modifications such as m6A in mRNA, albeit known since the 1980s, became amenable to transcriptome-wide analyses through the advent of next-generation sequencing techniques in a rather sudden manner. The term "mapping" here refers to detection of RNA modifications in a sequence context, which has a dramatic impact on the interpretation of biological functions. As a consequence, an impressive number of mapping techniques were published, most in the perspective of what now has become known as "epitranscriptomics". While more and more different modifications were reported to occur in mRNA, conflicting reports and controversial results pointed to a number of technical and theoretical problems rooted in analytics, statistics, and reagents. Rather than finding the proverbial needle in a haystack, the tasks were to determine how many needles of what color in what size of a haystack one was looking at.As the authors of this Account, we think it important to outline the limitations of different mapping methods since many life scientists freshly entering the field confuse the accuracy and precision of modification mapping with that of normal sequencing, which already features numerous caveats by itself. Indeed, we propose here to qualify a specific mapping method by the size of the transcriptome that can be meaningfully analyzed with it.We here focus on high throughput sequencing by Illumina technology, referred to as RNA-Seq. We noted with interest the development of methods for modification detection by other high throughput sequencing platforms that act directly on RNA, e.g., PacBio SMRT and nanopore sequencing, but those are not considered here.In contrast to approaches relying on direct RNA sequencing, current Illumina RNA-Seq protocols require prior conversion of RNA into DNA. This conversion relies on reverse transcription (RT) to create cDNA; thereafter, the cDNA undergoes a sequencing-by-synthesis type of analysis. Thus, a particular behavior of RNA modified nucleotides during the RT-step is a prerequisite for their detection (and quantification) by deep sequencing, and RT properties have great influence on the detection efficiency and reliability. Moreover, the RT-step requires annealing of a synthetic primer, a prerequisite with a crucial impact on library preparation. Thus, all RNA-Seq protocols must feature steps for the introduction of primers, primer landing sites, or adapters on both the RNA 3'- and 5'-ends.