General aspects and limits of conventional ultrafine WC powder manufacture and hard metal production

Abstract

Ultrafine WC/Co hard metals (average WC grain sizes ≤ 0.5 μm) can be successfully and reliably obtained by conventional hard metal manufacturing techniques. In this paper, some of the crucial aspects of conventional powder manufacture, powder milling and liquid phase sintering are discussed. Conventional ultrafine WC powder manufacture is based on the production of tungsten powder by hydrogen reduction of tungsten oxides and subsequent carburization. Alternatively, direct carburization can be carried out. However, inherent to the powder processing techniques used and the particle growth mechanisms involved (oxide precursors used, reduction and carburization history), there exists a lower limit beyond which-finer WC powders cannot be produced. This limit lies in the particle size range of 50–150 nm (0.05–0.15 μm). Powder milling is carried out to obtain an even dispersion of the Co binder in the ultrafine WC matrix. The more uniform the phase distribution (WC, Co, grain growth inhibitor) within the green powder compact, the more uniform will be the material transport during sintering, and hence the uniformity of the WC grain growth/growth inhibition during sintering. Enhanced WC grain growth occurs early in the sintering cycle, even below the temperature at which the liquid phase is formed. This growth can be largely restricted by the addition of VC. However, effective grain growth inhibition has to take place already during this early period of solid-state sintering. The ‘early’ availability of the grain growth inhibitor at the WC/Co interface can, therefore, determine the degree of growth inhibition. Ultrafine hard metals are in particular prone to discontinuous grain growth of the WC. Different reasons for this local growth mode are propounded relating to both the chemical as well as the geometrical departures from uniformity in the green powder compact. While it is still not possible to predict exactly an ultimate WC grain size limit, below which WC grain growth can no longer be restricted, even with proper inhibitor additions, experimental evidence indicates that this average WC grain size limit lies in the range of 200–300 nm. This limit is inherent to the existing conventional processing techniques (powder manufacture, milling, liquid phase sintering) and the WC growth mechanisms involved and can be overcome only by establishing a completely new route in hard metal manufacture.