Gender Effect on Political Leaders' Nonverbal Communicative Structure during the COVID-19 Crisis.

Tsfira Grebelsky-Lichtman,Roy Katz

doi:10.3390/ijerph17217789

Abstract

During the COVID-19 pandemic, there has been intense interest in political leaders’ nonverbal communicative structures (NCS) during televised appearances. This study analyzes the effect of gender on leaders’ NCS and presents theoretical and analytical frameworks of gendered NCS. We analyzed 20 televised appearances by 10 heads of state (five males and five females) from democratic Western countries during the COVID-19 pandemic. The findings revealed that gender had a significant effect on leaders’ NCS, indicating that leaders presented NCS that corresponded to their gender. Male leaders’ masculine NCS included competition, warning, threatening, and scaring behavior, broad proxemics, tension leakage, and illustrative gestures, while female leaders presented feminine NCS of cooperativeness, emotional communication, empathy, optimism, eye contact, and flexible expressions. Furthermore, the effect of gender on leaders’ NCS had an interaction effect with the situation of the pandemic, indicating that countries with a female leader had fewer diseased and severe cases and more calmness and healing NCS. The conclusions present theoretical and analytical frameworks that explain the central effect of gender on contemporary leaders’ NCS. This study develops advanced distinctive profiles for male versus female leaders’ NCS of emotions, cognition, and behavior during a crisis.

Highlights

Nonverbal communicative structure (NCS) has a central role in perceptions of politicians’leadership, charisma, confidence, and trust [1]
Leaders’ NCS during televised COVID-19 appearances express contemporary processes in the political communication of personalization [3,4] and emotionalism [5,6], which highlights the importance attributed to NCS
Female leaders presented significantly distinctive NCS compared to male leaders during the COVID-19 crisis

Summary

Introduction

Nonverbal communicative structure (NCS) has a central role in perceptions of politicians’leadership, charisma, confidence, and trust [1]. Leaders’ NCS is essential in affective communication, influence, and persuasion, especially during crisis and challenging periods of stress, fear, and uncertainty [2] (Wicks et al, 2017). People are highly sensitive to a leader’s NCS. This study analyzes gender effect on political leaders’ NCS in televised appearances during the COVID-19 crisis and develops a gender perspective of political communication that delineates gender differences in emotions, cognition, and behavior. The recent global health crisis has forced political leaders to face their people urgently through official televised COVID-19 appearances, to guide, inform, calm, and support. Leaders’ NCS during televised COVID-19 appearances express contemporary processes in the political communication of personalization [3,4] and emotionalism [5,6], which highlights the importance attributed to NCS

Objectives

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion