Gender differences in blood velocities across carotid stenoses

Abstract

Carotid duplex scanning is the standard test for documenting carotid disease. Carotid endarterectomy effectively reduces stroke in selected patients with carotid artery disease. Data from large national randomized trials suggest that the benefits of CEA may be gender dependent. Because many diagnoses are made and treatment is based on the results of carotid duplex ultrasound scanning alone, it is important to determine whether different diagnostic thresholds should be used in men and women. The purpose of this study was 2-fold: to examine whether there is an overall gender difference in carotid velocity at similar arteriographic stenoses, and to determine whether there are significant differences at clinically relevant thresholds of disease. A database of 938 carotid arteriogram entries was established prospectively, with accompanying measurements of peak systolic velocity (PSV) and end-diastolic velocity (EDV). The percent of internal carotid artery stenosis seen on arteriograms was calculated according to criteria from the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial. Analyses were made in 536 carotid arteries in men and 402 carotid arteries in women. In addition, the single most diseased artery per patient was analyzed by gender. PSV and EDV were averaged for data subsets according to 10% intervals of internal carotid artery stenoses. Velocity for each interval was compared between men and women with the Student t test. Receiver operator characteristic curves were developed to define optimal duplex criteria for 60% and 70% stenosis. For all intervals, PSV and EDV averaged 9% and 6% higher, respectively, in women than in men. Significant gender differences existed between PSV and EDV for 60% and 70% stenosis (P = .03). When a single vessel per patient was analyzed these observations persisted, but lost significance for PSV at 60% stenosis (P = .18). Receiver operator characteristic curves at 90% sensitivity demonstrated that optimal PSV for 60% stenosis was 160 cm/s and 180 cm/s, and for 70% stenosis was 185 cm/s and 202 cm/s, in male and female patients, respectively. Women have higher carotid blood flow velocity than men do. Gender differences exist, and are notably different at clinically relevant thresholds for intervention. These data indicate that different criteria should be used for interpreting carotid velocity profiles in women than in men, and have potentially important implications for patient care.