Gender, dietary restraint, and smoking's influence on hunger and the reinforcing value of food

Abstract

Smoking may enhance satiety following meal consumption, thereby reducing subsequent eating (i.e., between-meal snacks), especially in women high in dietary restraint. Female smokers ( n = 20, 10 high and 10 low restraint) and male smokers ( n = 10) participated in two sessions, involving overnight abstinence from food and smoking (smoking abstinence day) or from food only (smoking day), in a within-subjects design. The reinforcing value of food was determined by the number of responses made to obtain food reinforcers (100-kcal snack portions) vs. money using a concurrent schedules computer task. Subjects were given a small caloric load on each day followed by access to food vs. money. On the smoking day, subjects were allowed to smoke every 30 min during the session as well as ad lib before the session. Self-reported hunger was also assessed upon arrival (after fasting) and following the caloric load during each session. Results indicated no effect of smoking on initial hunger rating, after fasting, but hunger ratings following the caloric load declined significantly more during smoking vs. abstinence days for all subjects, consistent with an enhancement of postmeal satiety due to smoking. There was no overall main effect of smoking on food-reinforced responding. However, responding for food was significantly less during the smoking vs. abstinence days for high-restraint females only and not for low-restraint females or for males. These findings indicate that smoking's acute influence on reducing food intake does not reflect a broad gender difference but may be specific to dietary restraint.