Full-fat black soldier fly larvae meal and yellow mealworm meal: Impact on feed protein quality, growth and nutrient utilization of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) post smolts

Abstract

The shift towards insect-based alternatives in aquafeeds stems from the need to reduce the carbon footprint associated with the ingredients used in salmon feeds. In the present study, we describe the effects of full-fat insect meal incorporation on amino acid derivatives in feeds and the growth performance and nutrient utilization of Atlantic salmon post-smolts fed insect meals. A 74-day growth trial was conducted employing 520 fish (143 ± 12.8 g); these fish were fed either a control diet (CO) that contained 20 % fishmeal, 20 % soy protein concentrate (SPC), 14 % wheat gluten, 19 % plant raw materials, 13 % fish oil and 6 % rapeseed oil, or one of four insect meal diets, prepared with either 5 % and 10 % black soldier fly larvae meal (BS5, BS10) or 15 % and 30 % mealworm meal (MW15, MW30), by substituting mainly SPC, wheat gluten and rapeseed oil. The inclusion levels of BS and MW were determined based on their distinct chemical compositions, specifically their lipid content. As regards the results, HPLC-based high-throughput data on amino acid derivatives revealed the following: carboxymethyllysine was significantly higher in the MW30 feed than in BS5, BS10 and MW15 feeds; carboxyethyllysine was higher in the MW15 and MW30 feeds compared to the others; furosine was lower in the MW15 feed compared to the CO, BS5 and MW30 feeds. Regarding the effect of the insect meals on Atlantic salmon post-smolts, their inclusion had no significant effect on feed conversion ratio, health indicators and the retention efficiency of macronutrients. Apparent digestibility coefficients (ADC) of dry matter, lipid, ash and energy were not significantly different. However, protein digestibility in the 30 % MW group (80.4 %) was significantly lower (P ≤ 0.05) compared to the control and BS5 group (84.5 %). Furthermore, the ADC of protein was found to decrease linearly with increasing levels of insect meals, with MW showing a significant relationship (adjusted r2 = 0.77, p = 0.014). Overall, our study highlights the efficacy of 5 and 10 % BS and 15 % MW as ingredients in the feeds of Atlantic salmon. Other focal points included the undesirable amino acid derivatives and a reduction in protein digestibility associated with 30 % of MW in the diet of Atlantic salmon. Hence, future investigations should focus on the effects of feed processing conditions on the protein quality of mealworm before suggesting higher inclusion levels to the feed industry.