From parent-teacher relations to professional identity in Danish and Swedish schools

Abstract

ABSTRACT Denmark and Sweden have witnessed a historically significant amplification of parental influence in compulsory schools during the past two decades. The emphasis on parental involvement in these two countries reflects international trends of neoliberal governing of educational processes. We know very little about the interplay between beginning teachers’ encounters with parents and how that influences the teachers’ identity formation. This article investigates beginning teachers’ experiences with parents in Sweden and Denmark and how these experiences reflect the teachers’ professional identity development. Through a comparative case study approach, interviews were carried out with 10 teachers in pre-service and in-service phases of their profession to capture their interpretations of their experiences with parents. A framework involving the concepts of parent-teacher relations, professional teacher identity, and emerging and thickening trajectories was used to develop the interview questions and analyse data. The results show that beginning teachers experience challenges in their relations with parents and these challenges put a strain on their self-definition as professionals. These results provide implications for addressing the constraints on teachers’ professional autonomy brought by a culture of clientelism which has the potential to change the role of teachers and therefore affect their professional identity development.