FRI485 High Interlaboratory Variability In Free Thyroxine Measurement Indicates Need For Method Standardization

Abstract

Abstract Disclosure: A. Ribera: None. U. Danilenko: None. O. Sugahara: None. L. Collins: None. T. Buchannan: None. N. Vazquez: None. F. Pokuah: None. D. Wirtz: None. L. Zhang: None. A.N. Lyle: None. H.W. Vesper: None. Thyroid function tests are critical to diagnose diseases of the thyroid. Concerns about the accuracy and reliability of thyroid function tests, especially free thyroxine (FT4), have been stated by the clinical laboratory community for many years. In response to these concerns, the CDC Clinical Standardization Program (CSP) has created a standardization program for FT4 based on the International Federation of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (IFCC) reference system and is partnering with IFCC to standardize FT4 and harmonize TSH testing globally. As part of this program, CDC developed an accurate and sensitive reference measurement procedure (RMP) to assign reference values to individual donor sera. Assay manufacturers and research and clinical laboratories can use these sera to assess the analytical performance of their measurements, and monitor analytical performance over time. To obtain initial information about the analytical performance of FT4 and TSH measurements, an interlaboratory study among commercial assays and laboratory developed test was conducted. A panel of 40 blinded, fresh-frozen single donor patient serum samples with FT4 concentration ranging between 11-32 pmol/L concentrations was measured by participants and compared to the results obtained by CDC RMP for FT4. In addition, commercial assay manufacturers were asked to measure thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH). Results from sixteen commercial assays and four laboratory developed test (LDT) participated. Preliminary results indicate a negative mean bias for all commercial FT4 assays ranging from -34.46% to -5.08%. Some of the assays agreed more closely to the RMP than others (four assays had mean bias over -25%). An equilibrium dialysis mass spectrometry-based assays had mean biases ranging from -8.86% to - 1.72% agreeing well with RMP. The data suggest that the observed bias can be effectively minimized through recalibration to the RMPs operated by the CDC CSP and the IFCC reference laboratory network. The mean TSH concentrations ranged from 0.34 to 21.56 uIU/mL with mean %CV of 11.42% (95%CI 8.07%-14.76%) suggesting good agreement between various platforms. Findings from this study will be used to customize CDC’s protocols and procedures for standardizing FT4 measurements. Presentation: Friday, June 16, 2023