Formation of Archean greenstone belts: Insights from an assemblage-scale study in the western Superior craton

Abstract

Archean greenstone belts contain the oldest volcanic rocks on Earth and can provide critical insights into Earth’s early evolution. This study chooses the Sturgeon Lake greenstone belt in the easternmost Western Wabigoon terrane (WWT) of the Superior craton to illustrate an option for better understanding the formation of Archean greenstone belts. Our dataset includes outcrop observations, bulk compositions of 77 mafic to felsic volcanic samples, and in-situ U-Pb, Lu-Hf, and trace elements of zircon from 14 intermediate to felsic volcanic samples. The results revealed that this greenstone belt had broadly continuous volcanism from ca. 2780 to 2725 Ma, followed by a tectonic quiescence prior to a ca. 2707–2703 Ma volcanism at the terrane boundary. The intermediate volcanic rocks are characterized by variable Th/Nb and highly depleted Hf (zircon ƐHf(i) = +3 to + 6), interpreted to be derived from mantle sources ranging from those of normal mid-ocean ridge basalts (N-MORB) to those of enriched MORB (E-MORB), which commonly assimilated various felsic crustal components. The mafic volcanic rocks are dominated by low La/Sm basalts with negligible Nb, Ta anomalies and limited range of Th/Nb, forming a mantle array on the Th/Yb-Nb/Yb plot and consistent with oceanic crust of N-MORB to enriched N-MORB affinities. Some basalts from the ca. 2738–2725 Ma assemblages, however, gave high La/Sm, negative Nb and Ta anomalies, and limited range of Th/Nb plotting above and parallel to the mantle array. These basalts might be associated with passive subcretion and rollback of oceanic crust of the stagnant-lids tectonics or subduction of oceanic lithosphere as in modern-style plate tectonics, both of which are supported by trace element compositions of zircon that indicate hydrous, oxidized, large-ion lithophile element-enriched, and medium- to high-pressure magmas. Identification of three magma-series would not be possible if the data were lumped together, which is commonly seen in terrane- or craton-scale studies that sometimes propose contrasting interpretations of rock origins and Archean geodynamic processes. This detailed approach of distinguishing rock types and zooming into the subunits of a greenstone belt offers a practical solution to more accurately characterize Archean volcanic rocks and to better understand the early Earth.