Fluticasone propionate 1 mg daily and beclomethasone dipropionate 2 mg daily: a comparison over 1 yr

Abstract

This study was designed primarily to assess the safety and tolerability of fluticasone propionate (FP) 1 mg day −1 by comparison with beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP) 2 mg day −1 over a 12-month study period. Lung function data were also recorded and used to determine whether the potency ratio between the two inhaled corticosteroids observed in previous studies was maintained in the long-term. Two hundred and thirteen patients with an established clinical history of severe chronic asthma and who were currently receiving between 1000 μg and 2000 μg day −1 of inhaled steroids were randomized to treatment in a ratio of 3:1 for FP:BDP (159 patients FP; 54 patients BDP), both via metered dose inhalers. Both treatments were well tolerated with a similar adverse event profile. No unexpected adverse events were recorded. Most adverse events were related to the patients' asthma, an intercurrent infection or underlying atopy. The incidence of pharmacologically predictable adverse events was equally low in both treatment groups as was the incidence of events suggestive of systemic steroid effect. Mean serum cortisol levels remained within the normal range at all visits for both treatments. At 12 months, however, the mean cortisol levels for the FP group had risen 4% above the baseline value but had dropped 15% below for the BDP group, giving a ratio of FP:BDP of 1·22; P=0·01; 95% confidence limits (CL) 1·05–1·43. Fluticasone propionate 1 mg day −1 was at least as effective as BDP 2 mg day −1 in improving lung function (PEF, FEV 1 and FVC) over this period. Moreover, the difference in FEV 1 values at 6 months was significantly greater for the FP group than for the BDP group ( P=0·04; difference=0·12 l; 95% CL=0·01, 0·24 l). The difference between treatments in the amount of FEV 1 reversibility was also significantly greater for FP at 12 months (difference in treatments = −3%; 95% CL = −7-0%; P=0·044). This study supports previous studies and suggests that FP is likely to be of benefit in the long-term treatment of chronic severe asthma.