Fitting Type Ia Supernova Data to a Cosmological Model Based on Einstein–Newcomb–De Sitter Space

Abstract

Einstein–Newcomb–de Sitter (ENdS) space is de Sitter’s modification of spherical space used by Einstein in his first cosmological model paper published in 1917. The modification by de Sitter incorporated the topological identification of antipodal points in space previously proposed by Newcomb in 1877. De Sitter showed that space topologically modified in this way (called elliptical or projective space) satisfies Einstein’s field equations. De Sitter also found that in a space with constant positive curvature, spectral lines of remote galaxies would be red-shifted (called the de Sitter effect). However, de Sitter’s formulae relating distances to red shifts do not satisfy observational data. The likely reason for this mismatch is that de Sitter mainly focused on space curvature and ignored the identification of antipodal points. Herein, we demonstrate that it is this particular feature that allows an almost perfect fit of the ENdS-based cosmological model to observational data. We use 1701 sources from the type Ia supernovae data sample called Pantheon+, which was previously used to fit the ΛCDM model. ΛCDM and ENdS diverge in their predictions for red shifts exceeding z∼2.3. Since there are no available type Ia supernovae (SNe) data for higher red shifts, both models can be validated by using an additional sample of 193 gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) spanning red shifts up to z∼8. This validation shows that the minimum χ2 for the SNe+GRBs sample is about 2.7% smaller for the ENdS space model than for the ΛCDM model.