Fish stocks as phosphorus sources or sinks: Influenced by nutritional and metabolic variations, not solely by dietary content and stoichiometry

Abstract

The study provides a descriptive understanding of when fish (Cyprinus carpio model) are the source or sink of phosphorus. Dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP; PO4-P) losses (51.1 ± 5.9 % of intake-P) increase at excess of bioavailable P (>0.83 g 100 g−1 dry matter, DM fed) or when food (digestible) N:P mass ratio (≤4.4:1) approaches organismal storage threshold (~4:1). This is known, however, even at a sub-threshold food P content (0.57 g 100 g−1 DM) and food N:P mass ratio (7.3:1), DRP losses (57.8 ± 4.5 % of intake-P) may be extraordinary if two indispensable amino acids are biologically insufficient (lysine ≤1.43 g, methionine ≤0.39 g 100 g−1 DM fed). Given that methionine and lysine are sufficient, DRP losses cease (≈0 %) and even some P from water is absorbed, given there is support from non-protein energy (NPE). Insufficient NPE (<180 kcal 100 g−1 DM fed) may drive DRP losses (81.6 ± 4.3 % of intake-P) beyond expected levels (46–59 % of intake-P) at a given food P content (0.91 g 100 g−1 DM). Natural food seldom fulfills low P, high lysine + methionine, and high NPE contents simultaneously, thus keeping fish in a perpetual P recycling for algae (scaleless carp > scaly carp). Such P recycling ceases only during basal metabolism. During feeding state, the richness of lysine + methionine bound N and lipid + carbohydrate bound C in the food base may enhance the fishes' threshold of P storage. P storage can be diminished when they are insufficient. We show that for fish, the decision of P recycling or not recycling (for algae) may change based on the supply of specific fractions of N or C from the food web or metabolic variations (basal metabolism, presence of scales). Novelty statementThe ecological stoichiometry theory is better connected to fish nutritional bioenergetics for better understanding and biomanipulation of eutrophication processes.