First phylogenetic analysis of the Nearctic madicolous midges of the genus Androprosopa Mik (Diptera: Thaumaleidae)

Abstract

Molecular phylogenetic analyses were conducted to infer relationships between the eastern and western Nearctic Androprosopa Mik and amongst the considerably more diverse western Nearctic species. Fresh, molecular-grade material was obtained for all Nearctic Androprosopa species except two Mexican species, An. sonorensis (Arnaud & Boussy) and An. zempoala Sinclair & Huerta, that eluded capture. Molecular sequences from two nuclear protein-coding genes, big zinc finger (BZF) and molybdenum cofactor sulfurase (MCS), were sampled from representatives of several outgroup and ingroup taxa and analyzed phylogenetically using maximum likelihood criteria to confirm identifications of females and immatures using a barcoding approach, test species boundaries among morphologically similar species, and infer relationships among more morphologically disparate groups. Resulting phylogenies suggest the following with significant node (bootstrap) support: (1) the eastern Nearctic Androprosopa species form the sister group to the lineage comprised of all sampled Palearctic thaumaleids, i.e., An. larvata (Mik), An. striata (Okada), and Thaumalea testacea Ruthe; (2) the aforementioned lineage is the sister group to the clade comprised of western Nearctic Androprosopa species; (3) the western Nearctic Androprosopa species form three multispecies lineages, two of which can be further divided into three or more well founded species groups. Our results suggest that Androprosopa as currently defined is paraphyletic. Additionally, we propose several new species groups within the western Nearctic Androprosopa based on molecular and morphological data.