FINGER FORECASTING: A Pointer to Athletic Prowess in Women A Preliminary Investigation by an Undergraduate Biology Class

Abstract

With all the technology today, we were surprised to read a recent British study (Paul et al., 2006) that found a connection between the of a woman's index (2D) and ring (4D) fingers to her athletic ability (Figure 1). This sounded more like an article for palm readers than scientists. Upon further investigation we found that many studies have examined the relationship between the of the index finger (2D) to the ring finger (4D) and have linked this ratio to such things as human fertility, behavior, and health (Manning et al., 1998; Manning, 2002; Manning et al., 2003; Kassim et al., 2004, Bailey & Hurd, 2005). Who knew that fingers could provide such a broad range of information? The British study suggested that women with a low 2D:4D ratio would be better athletes than those with a high 2D:4D ratio. One scientist even went as far as to state, If you had a group of runners and they were about to start a race, I could predict reasonably well who was going to win based on their finger length (BBC News, 2005). As educators, we take a research-based approach with our courses and thought it might be interesting to incorporate this study into our college freshmen Bio 101 General Biology course. What would their hands reveal? [FIGURE 1 OMITTED] The plan of action was to measure index and ring fingers from both the male and female students in the class; these served as our controls. Next, the students collected from women athletes. We compared the various women athletic groups to our controls. Would our data support the findings of the British study? As mentioned, many studies have examined the 2D:4D ratio. This ratio was determined by measuring on the palm side of the right hand the of the index finger (2D) and dividing it by the of the ring finger (4D) (Figure 1). High 2D:4D ratios occur when the index finger is longer than the ring finger; low 2D:4D ratios have an index finger that is shorter than the ring finger (Figure 2). Some research suggested that these 2D:4D ratios were determined in the womb, prenatally. Scientists have also studied the connection between the 2D:4D ratios and variation in the androgen receptor gene which is located on the X chromosome (Manning et al., 2003). The androgen receptor gene contains a stretch of CAG repeats encoding glutamines within its sequence (Figure 3). The range of the number of repeats can be 1140, with an average between 20-22 CAG repeats (Chang, Kokontis & Liao, 1988). The number of CAG repeats can alter the binding of the hormone receptor complex to DNA (Manning et al., 2003). As a result, the number of the CAG triplets is negatively associated to the level of sensitivity to testosterone (Chamberlain et al., 1994). The basic theory of these studies is that higher levels of testosterone during the first nine weeks of development within the womb would assist the growth of the ring finger, while exposure to higher levels of estrogen would facilitate the growth of the index finger. The number of CAG trinucleotide repeats within the androgen receptor gene could possibly alter how sensitive/insensitive humans were to testosterone concentrations and, as a result, determine the of these digits. Our study in the general biology course first examined the 2D:4D ratios of our control and test groups and then tried to analyze DNA samples to determine if any differences in CAG repeats occurred. Methods Hand Measurements Each hand was captured by using a copy machine. Prior to copying the right hand, a black dot was drawn in the crease where the finger of both the index and ring fingers attached to the hand. Rings were removed to ensure that we could see exactly where the fingers attached to the hand. The hand was copied palm-side-down next to a ruler. Once a copy of the hand was made, the of the index finger (2D) was measured (in centimeters) and divided by the of the ring finger (4D) to determine the 2D:4D ratio (Figure 1). …