Fine-needle aspiration diagnosis of Hodgkin lymphoma using current WHO classification—Re-evaluation of cases from 1999–2004 with new proposals

Abstract

With the advent of modern therapy, the differences in prognoses and treatment regimens among different subtypes of Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) have largely vanished. Stage and the presence of systemic symptoms are much more important than histologic subtypes as predictive factors. The current (2001) WHO classification markedly de-emphasizes spatial relationships as critical to the diagnosis of lymphoma and emphasizes cell morphology, immunophenotype, genetic features, and clinical information to define the disease states. This classification, thus, greatly enhances the capability of fine-needle aspiration (FNA) to accurately diagnose HL. We searched all the FNA cases in our institute in years 1999 through 2004 and found 42 cases, for which 13 were primarily diagnosed (31.0%), 2 were recurrent (4.8%), 5 were highly suspicious (11.9%), and 22 were suspicious (52.3%) for HL. On follow-up tissue biopsy, all the primarily diagnosed, recurrent, and highly suspicious cases were confirmed to be HL (100% agreement). For the 22 suspicious cases, 13 were HL (59.1%), 5 were other lymphomas (22.8%), 1 was lymphoma unclassifiable (4.5%), and 3 were reactive processes (13.6%). The effect of immunostains on the diagnosis of HL was examined, and its importance was emphasized. Analysis of demographic data and the distribution of HL subtypes demonstrate that the study sample is representative of the general HL patient population. On the basis of these results, we propose: (1) If the FNA diagnosis of HL is confirmed both by morphology and immunostains, no further tissue confirmation, subclassification and grading is necessary, and appropriate treatment regimens should follow. (2) The nodular lymphocyte predominant HL and classical HL can be differentiated by adequate immunostaining. (3) If a definitive diagnosis cannot be achieved by FNA, a second FNA or a tissue biopsy should be recommended.