Field Evaluation of a Commercial Formulation of the Spodoptera exigua (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Nuclear Polyhedrosis Virus for Control of Beet Armyworm on Vegetable Crops in Thailand

Abstract

Small - scale field trials were conducted in the Kanchanaburi and Ratchaburi provinces of Thailand between December 1994 and March 1996 to gather efficacy data to support a registration dossier for a commercial formulation of a nuclear polyhedrois virus of beet armyworm , Spodoptera exigua, under the tradename Spod - X . A liquid concentrate formula tion of Spod - X was compared with two commercial standards , Bacillus thuringiensis subsp . aizawai (CenTuri 3 . 5 WDG) and the insect growth regulator tebufenozide (Mimic 20F , a benzoylhydrazine ecdysone agonist) , for control of beet armyworm on garden pea , Chinese kale , shallot and table grape . Spod - X applied at 4 - day intervals at 3 . 1 - 12 . 5 1011 occlusion bodies (OBs) ha 1 in a spray volume of 625 - 1000 l ha 1 provided excellent control of beet armyworm on garden pea and grape (75 - 100 % reductions) after the second application . On Chinese kale and shallot , rates of Spod - X in the rate 5 - 60 1011 OBs ha 1 sprayed every 4 days in a spray volume of 1000 l ha 1 provided significant protection from infestation of beet armyworm over the growing season; however , efficacy was poor to moderate . Tank - mixing Spod - X with the pyrethroid , deltamethrin (Decis3EC) , did not improveefficacy on shallot;however , combinations of virus and B. thuringiensis or tebufenozide achieved commercially acceptable levels of crop protection on Chinese kale compared with virus alone . Lower levels of control and crop pro tection observed with all materials on Chinese kale and shallot reflect , in part , the tendency of S. exigua larvae to feed within sheltered sites and directly damage marketable plant parts . In general , all rates of Spod - X performed as well as , or better than , the B. thuringiensis standard (56 . 3 - 105 g ha 1 a.i.) on all crops tested . In general , reductions of beet armyworm larval populations and plant damage provided by all labeled rates of the chemical standard , tebufenozide (125 - 250 g ha 1 a . i .), were marginally greater than all rates of Spod - X tested . On crops such as pea and grape , where beet armyworm predominately feed on exposed leaf surfaces , our data unequivocally support the use of Spod - X for cost - effective , season - long pest management . Strategies to improve the efficacy of virus on shallot and kale are discussed .